February 9th, 2008 Posted in television | Comments Off
Despite my initial assessment of ABC’s Cashmere Mafia still holding firm, I have found myself helplessly charmed by the show. Perhaps the word “charmed” is too strong, but there is a vague attraction to the show. Mafia is like dating someone that is nice enough and there are moments of potential, potent attraction, but those moments pass, so you keeping seeing them, hoping that one of those moments catch fire and you find yourself head over heels in love. Right now, Mafia, we are still stuck in the friends zone.

Cashmere Mafia is a ship without a course, floating directionless and limp across the open sea. The actors are charming enough and their chemistry has settled into a nice easy flow that does lend itself to the notion that these four women would hang out, but other than that, we’ve got a big, fat nothing. What the writers of this show don’t seem to get (or not least are not doing well enough) is that in these types of shows, we keep tuning in for a narrative payoff. Remember back to the first season of Grey’s Anatomy, when we were all on pins and needles waiting for the moment when people would find out that McDreamy and Meredith were hooking up on the sly. Payoff. Or, better still, the first season of Veronica Mars, where the season was working towards the resolution of Lilly Kane’s murder, not to mention who took Veronica’s virginity. Dramatic. Payoff. Right now, Cashmere Mafia hasn’t established any story arcs that will keep me invested in the show. The show’s only saving grace, besides its talented cast, is that television is a virtual wasteland and the show is more interesting than watching paint dry.. barely.
As someone who would love this show to turn things around, mainly because I think all four actresses are up to the challenge of better material, here are five things that could, possibly, save Cashmere Mafia from itself.
Dump Caitlin’s gay storyline … until you get the balls to do it right.
I am beginning to think we are decades away from a network series handling a gay storyline the way it should be handled. We still treat “the gay” as this odd state of existence akin to having six fingers or a third nostril, some freakish “difference” that defines gay characters so completely that it leaves little room for an actual, you know, character. Five episodes into this show, we know Caitlin, the show’s token gay woman … or bisexual… or straight gal, she hasn’t figured out which, about as well as we know that uncle who used to visit us once every two years during Christmas. In other words, not at all. It is not a stretch to say this storyline has been as explicit as 1961’s The Children’s Hour, but lets hope the lesbian doesn’t hang herself at the end of this one. I would like to believe it is network meddling that is putting the breaks on her character development and her romance with girlfriend. Somehow that pains me less than thinking that the writers feel they have sufficiently serviced this character and her storyline because, newsflash, not working.
My solution: Deep-six the storyline. Caitlin and her girlfriend end their relationship, but leave the door open for possible exploration later, you know, when you have the balls to tell it right. Caitlin realizes that shutting the door on half the planet’s population is not the best plan to finding a soulmate.
For the love of God, use your cellphones.
One of the more ridiculous things we are forced to swallow in this show is that these high-powered women in power can drop everything to have impromptu lunches, dinner and drinks with their gal pals, yet have to schedule time with their kids. Not only are these people bad parents, but do you really expect me to believe no one in their offices are looking for them while they are off gossip with their friends. We live in the digital age, people. These women don’t need to see each other every damn day to be up in each other’s business. It’s called email, texting, conference calls and cellphones. They should be in constant contact with each other, their bluetooth ear pieces firmly in place, planning their outfits for their next important meeting. Perhaps, there is a bit of resentment on my part since they cut my favorite scene from the original pilot.
My solution: More blackberry addiction. More conference calls. More interaction via the ‘net. That’s how my friends and I roll. Also, for a group of friends who seem to be as close as these four women are, it surprises me that they are not more involved in each other’s family lives. You would think these women would spend their weekends brunching at each other houses, with their boys talking business in the next room and their kids running around the living room.
Don’t make other women look like morons, sluts, gold-diggers or all of the above.
Five episodes into this damn show, I don’t think we met a woman not part of their group who wasn’t some combination of vindictive, evil, stupid and slutty. Zoe’s assistant, Katherine, takes the cake as the show’s most offensive creation, a woman who has slept her way up the corporate ladder and is the epitome of every stereotype this show is supposedly trying to stamp out. Way to go.
My solution: Introduce a couple of other powerful women who struggle with the same issues of “having it all” and perhaps other women who aren’t as high up on the corporate ladder, but who aren’t, you know, whores. Just a thought.
Make Them Work Together
One of the problems with a show based on friendships rather than, say, a work environment (i.e. all characters working at the same place) is the constant struggle to make sure everyone gets their equal share of screentime, but also make the script feel like one whole story, instead of little vignettes viewers are jerked away from every few minutes. Right now, this is exactly what the show feels like, mini-stories, none of them fully developed, in an episode that feels more like a tossed than a beautifully proportioned main course. Is anyone else suddenly hungry? Admittedly, this one is probably the show’s biggest issue and the hardest to solve.
My solution: Are you telling me that an executive in the hotel business, the cosmetics business and the publishing business couldn’t find a project that would find them working together? In New York City? I find that hard to believe. I mean, hello, FASHION WEEK or the hundreds of other events that would find these businesses in each other’s radars. You would think these friends would find ways to work together. We kill two birds with one stone here, combining a few character’s storylines, but each staying within their own arenas. Another idea could be a story arc that involved one of the women losing her job only to be hired by their close friend and the fallout of your friend suddenly becoming your boss. Comedy gold, right there. Are you writing these ideas down?
Delve More Into Their Pasts
We still don’t know the circumstances of how these women became friends and frankly, I’d love to see the first time tough-talking, snarky Caitlin first laid eyes on ice queen Juliet. And what group of friends doesn’t constantly reference the past in normal conversation? I don’t think this will help the show story wise, but it would certainly provide the characters some much needed texture.
My solution: The Mafia’s fifteen university reunion is coming up which causes some old stories and old tensions to stir up among the group. Awkward flashbacks are optional in this episode.
technorati tags: cashmere mafia